Victoria has tightened its rules on advertised price guides repeatedly since 2017, and has enforced them with a dedicated taskforce since 2022. A new research report from the Australian Property Institute (API), prepared with support from Homer, asks a simple question: does the guide buyers see tell them what a home will sell for?
The Victorian Guide Gap draws on Homer's record of Victorian sales campaigns. Its core analysis covers 102,681 residential sales from July 2025 to June 2026, each compared with the first guide the agent advertised. Its answer is that most of the time it doesn't, and least of all at auction.
This article walks through what the report found from Homer's data, in plain terms. You can read the full report or the AFR's coverage.
Victoria's price-guide rules sit in Part IIA of the Estate Agents Act 1980, in force since May 2017.
Homer keeps a record of residential sales campaigns advertised online in Victoria. The report uses campaigns that ended in a sale, with sale prices taken from the major listing portals and checked against independent sale records.
A sale is within the guide if it lands between the bottom and the top, over if it lands above the top, and under if it lands below the bottom. That is a stricter test than Homer's own agent grades, which measure from the guide minimum to 10% above it and allow a small buffer at each edge.
Fewer than half of Victorian homes, 42.7%, sold within their first advertised guide in the year to June 2026. At auction, 67.1% landed outside it. In private sale, 52.1% did.
The two sale methods miss in different ways. Between July and December 2025, 22.1% of auction sales sold 10% or more above the top of the guide. The average auction sale in that half landed 6.0% outside its guide, against 2.4% for private sales.
Auctions are almost entirely a Melbourne market: Greater Melbourne holds 97% of Victoria's auctions. Private sale is different. About six in ten regional private sales landed outside the guide, mostly below it.
An accurate estimate is sometimes too high and sometimes too low, in roughly equal measure. So the report counts, month by month, how many sales landed above the top of the guide for every one that landed below the bottom. A ratio near 1 means the misses are balanced.
In September and October 2025, there were 8.6 and 9.4 auction sales above the guide for every one below it. Private-sale guides in the same months sat at 1.03 and 1.02: an even split. More auction sales landed above the guide than below it in eleven months out of twelve. In the second half of 2025, nearly nine in ten auction sales that landed outside their guide (87.8%, among sales advertised with a range) landed above it.
Private-sale guides were balanced only as prices peaked. In the other nine months, more private sales landed below the guide than above it, down to 0.16 in June 2026, about one above for every six below.
The report builds composite campaigns from the middle values of every campaign that followed a pattern. They show what the auction and private-sale figures mean for a single home. Both are from July to December 2025.
The obvious objection is that prices were rising, so of course homes sold above the guide. Prices and above-guide sales do move together, and rising prices do lift auction results past the guide. The report runs three checks to show they don't explain the gap itself, or why auction and private guides miss in opposite directions.
Auction guides did look more accurate in 2026: the share of auction sales inside the guide rose from 28.7% to 38.3%. The report finds that came mostly from prices falling to meet guides that hadn't moved, and from more homes not selling at all, rather than from better guides.
Four auction sales in ten between July and December 2025 landed 5% or more above the top of the guide they were advertised against. The report tests whether that was the work of a small group of agents. Mostly, it wasn't. A small group does stand out, but agents who fit none of the report's behaviour patterns made 75.6% of those sales. Not every sale above the guide is a problem: a competitive auction can carry an honest guide a long way.
The report also tests auction guides against what similar homes had recently sold for: the same suburb, type and bedroom count, in the three months before the campaign. From July to December 2025, the median auction guide had its top 0.5% below that evidence and its bottom 8.1% below it. The median sale then landed 3.2% above it.
Consumer Affairs Victoria set up a dedicated Underquoting Taskforce in September 2022, and it was made permanent in August 2024. Scoring every sale since January 2021 the same way, the share of homes selling within their guide was 39.6% before the taskforce, 40.3% while it operated and 42.1% since it became permanent. Six homes in ten sold outside their guide in every period.
The share measures outcomes, not conduct. Most earlier campaigns advertised a single figure rather than a range, so part of any change between periods may reflect that mix: on advertised ranges alone, the shares were 43.0%, 41.3% and 47.1%.
What has changed is the direction of the misses. Sales landing 10% or more below the bottom of the guide nearly doubled, from 2.4% of all sales before the taskforce to 4.7% under the permanent program. Guides set too high are not what the underquoting rules are designed to catch.
The report closes with the Australian Property Institute's policy recommendation: an independent valuation before a home is advertised, disclosed to buyers. The API sets out its proposal, and what it's asking for, in its own announcement.
Homer's agent grades look at a related question for individual agents: how often their sales land within the guide, and how often well outside it. They use a different, more forgiving window than the report (from the guide minimum to 10% above it, with a small buffer at each edge), so grades can't be compared directly with the report's figures. Each grade is worked out from both the first and the final guide, and the lower grade stands, so lowering a guide to meet the sale doesn't lift the grade. Grades are Homer's own measure, not part of the report, and a grade describes past results against advertised guides: it isn't a finding that an agent has broken the law. Read how the grades work.
The Australian Property Institute, with support from Homer. The analysis is built on Homer's records of Victorian sales campaigns. The recommendation is the API's.
Not on its own. The law requires a reasonable estimate based on comparable sales, advertised at no less than that estimate. The report measures where guides sat against comparable sales and where homes sold. It doesn't determine whether any individual agent met their legal obligations.
The sale landed between the bottom and the top of the first advertised guide. A single advertised figure is treated as the bottom of a range with a top 10% above it, the widest range the law allows.
It's the figure buyers act on, and the one the vendor was given when choosing the agent. A guide can be moved during the campaign until it meets the eventual price.
No. Its data ends before the rules requiring the reserve to be published at least seven days before auction, which apply from 16 October 2026.
No. The report applies fixed tests to every agent in the same way, and no agent, office or address is named.